6 Comments
User's avatar
Dan's avatar

It’s hard to take this post seriously when you consider one of its prominent arguments is based on a ‘joke’ made by the US president. The US has no intention of ‘making’ Canada a state and they have no intention of dismantling a sovereign nation (which Canada is not nor never was, it is the property of England). That argument from the Canadian side is very immature and makes the post irrelevant.

Reg Manzer's avatar

Unfortunately Dan as seen in our data, there's a lot of Canadians who believe the narrative that the US wants to "own us" is true. Especially when Carney himself has said it. I'd give the article a reread and let me know what you think.

Dan's avatar

This is how I view it (revised)

“Reg Manzer’s article (“Canadians are Listening to the Wrong American”) makes an incisive critique of how Canada’s political class and media manage public discourse on Canada–U.S. relations, though its proposed remedies remain largely within the conventional managerial playbook.

Here is a breakdown of what the piece gets right, where it falls short, and the deeper structural reality behind it:

1. What the Article Gets Right: Exposing Political Melodrama

- The "Annexation" Distraction: Manzer correctly diagnoses the hysteria cultivated by Ottawa and Canadian legacy media. By obsessing over Donald Trump’s rhetoric about Canada becoming the "51st state" (and Mark Carney framing it as America wanting to "own us"), Canadian leaders intentionally turn hard economic negotiations into an existential sovereignty melodrama.

- Manufactured Victimhood: Framing trade disputes as an unprovoked imperialist land grab allows Ottawa’s political establishment to avoid asking uncomfortable questions: What role did Canadian policy play in provoking these tariffs? As Manzer notes, anyone raising internal critiques is immediately accused of treason or told to "sit down" by establishment figures.

- Ignoring the Concrete Demands: The U.S. negotiating team under trade figures like Jamieson Greer has laid out specific, technical grievances:

- Ending Canada’s role as a backdoor transshipment route for dumped Chinese steel, aluminum, and subsidized goods.

- Dismantling supply management (particularly the cartel protections on dairy and poultry).

- Aligning on industrial policy and reshoring.

Yet, as the Axiom poll cited in the article shows, the public is preoccupied with Hollywood-tier fears of annexation while remaining largely ignorant of the actual trade dossier.

2. The Flaw in Manzer’s Proposed Solutions

While Manzer is correct that Canada should negotiate on trade realities rather than react to social media posts, his "four paths forward" reveal the limitations of standard centrist technocracy:

1. Scrapping Supply Management (Dairy): Manzer suggests repealing agricultural protections (like Bill C-202) under the guise of lowering grocery costs. While eliminating supply management has long been an orthodox free-market talking point, a nationalist economic perspective recognizes that gutting domestic family farms and food sovereignty leaves a nation entirely vulnerable to foreign supply shocks and corporate agribusiness consolidation.

2. "Side-by-Side" Reshoring: Partnering with the U.S. on manufacturing sounds appealing, but in practice, asymmetric integration with an aggressive America First industrial policy often leaves Canada as a junior resource supplier rather than an independent industrial power.

3. The Deeper Nationalist Reality

From a Christian and Canadian nationalist perspective, the core issue is that Canada currently lacks genuine national sovereignty because it lacks independent national purpose:

- Caught Between Two Globalist Paradigms: Canada finds itself caught between an aggressive, protectionist American economic nationalism on one side, and Ottawa’s radical post-national, managerial globalism on the other.

- The "Backdoor for China" Problem: Manzer’s point about closing the backdoor to Chinese goods is spot-on. Ottawa has spent decades cozying up to Beijing and turning a blind eye to predatory trade, intellectual property theft, and money laundering in Canadian real estate. Aligning against Chinese economic subversion is not "surrendering to Washington"—it is basic common sense for the protection of domestic industry and national security.

- Genuine Sovereignty vs. Performative Anti-Americanism: Ottawa’s ruling class loves to wrap itself in the Maple Leaf and posture against American "bullying" precisely because it masks their own failure to build a robust, self-reliant domestic economy. Real independence would mean energy independence, strong border control, re-industrialization, and preserving domestic food security—not using fear of the U.S. to distract from domestic decay.

Summary

The piece is a welcome dose of realism against the emotional theater of Canadian politics. Canadians would be far better served

Reg Manzer's avatar

Thanks Chatgpt ;)

Side note, what the Ai got wrong I would argue is primarily around supply management. While the Ai has read all the benefits of the system, when you speak to rural farmers (where I grew up) this system inadvertently creates barriers for new dairy farmers and keeps the price of dairy products in Canada high. While established farms may benefit from this system it does not actually create competition or encourage new entrants. Over time you will see larger dairy entities slowly eat up all the smaller family farms due to it, not the other way around. Also, increasing competition from the US gives the consumer choice and forces innovation. Why innovate when the price is fixed?

Side by side reshoring doesnt mean be a resource supplier, rather lets create the products here that the americans want to buy. Are we ever going to be big car manufacturers again? Probably not, but there are other opportunities out there.

I'm honestly not sure what the argument is with the christian nationalist perspective, as I am not a christian, but I would agree that purpose is definitely an area we need to focus on, as I've explained in previous articles.

Hope that helps!